Mt 7:12 Therefore, whatever you want men to do to you, thus also you do to them, for this is the Law and the Prophets.
How would you feel if someone tried to convert you to their religion in a Starbucks?
How would you feel if someone who hardly knew you pointed out your sins?
How would you feel if someone had zero interest in you except to sway you towards his beliefs?
How would you feel when you see him again? Would you be excited or would you run the other way?
Is this how your non church neighbor perceives you?
The greatest evangelism is the listening ear over a plate of food.
What about inviting your non church friend to lunch and listen to his story?